How to Hire a CRO Consultant -

About
Latest Posts

Nicole is a marketing creative with more than 15 years of experience helping small and mid-sized businesses connect with their audiences. Over the years, she’s worked across industries and content formats, giving her a practical perspective on what makes marketing clear, useful, and effective. When she’s not thinking about what makes good marketing actually work, she’s usually busy keeping up with her two young boys.

Review what happens after customers convert

It’s tempting to start with a simple goal such as getting more form submissions. But prior to setting targets, look at what those form submissions are doing for your business.

Let’s say the goal is to get more “request a quote” submissions from Google Ads campaigns. You might jump to the conclusion that removing a few questions from the form will increase conversions.

However, those exact questions might be what was qualifying the lead by identifying whether they needed the service or could actually afford it. Cut out those questions, and your sales team will be spending their time chasing unqualified inquiries instead of selling. Yes, simplifying the form submission process can make your conversion rate look better. But if those leads aren’t qualified, your business didn’t gain anything from it.

A useful hiring brief will explain to a CRO consultant both the action you want people to take and the reason it matters. For example, a service business wants more quote requests that turn into bookings or an ecommerce brand needs more purchases that don’t rely on discounts because they leave little profit.

There doesn’t have to be a perfect measurement system in place before you hire a CRO consultant. But you do need to explain what a better result looks like for your brand, not just a higher number in a report, because an experienced consultant needs to understand that connection early.

Figure out if you need strategy, execution or both

Once you have defined your goal, look at what you know about the problem. It helps avoid hiring someone to build a solution you’re assuming you need.

Imagine a user clicking on your ad that is customized for a specific product, but they land on a general page that lists all of your products. Rewriting the headline could help, but the bigger problem is that visitors end up searching for the product instead of easily landing on it. This is why you need to look at the ad and page together before deciding what to fix.

For another brand, the problem might be crystal clear. Multiple users have reported a broken checkout field, and the team needs help fixing and testing it. Paying for a lengthy discovery process would be difficult to justify.

These situations require different types of support. So if you don’t know why people leave, look for a CRO consultant that is experienced in analytics, customer research, and customer journey analysis. But if you already have the data and a list of clear fixes, look for someone who can execute.

Some consultants are capable of doing both, so ask where their abilities stop. Landing page optimization can mean giving a list of recommendations, writing the copy, or building and testing the page, and all of these differences matter when you’re paying the final invoice.

The plan should fit your traffic and team

Before you sign off on an ongoing testing program, make sure the pace makes sense for your business.

High website traffic doesn’t hold much value if the specific page you’re testing barely gets any visitors. If only a handful of people reach that page, splitting them in half to run an A/B test means you’ll be waiting months to get reliable results.

An experienced consultant will analyze your page traffic and conversion rates beforehand, using sample-size calculators to predict how long the test will actually take.

Watch out for consultants that promise a set number of monthly tests before reviewing your numbers. If your numbers are too low for trustworthy A/B tests in the first place, those monthly promises are a red flag.

Rather than running traffic-heavy tests, a smaller audience means you need to rely on other methods like customer interviews, usability sessions, and support logs. These types of numbers won’t exactly tell you conversion rates, but they can show where people are getting stuck.

It’s also important to consider your team’s capacity. For example if a consultant recommends making multiple changes a week, but your developer is only available once a month, the plan is broken before it even starts.

Clearly line out everyone’s responsibilities, like who can update pages, approve copy, and review that the changes work properly. Or else, you end up paying for recommendations that keep getting pushed to the next month.

Determine how much help you need prior to hiring

By establishing how much help you need, it’s much easier to decide whether you’re looking for a short term project, an on-going consultant, or a full agency partner.

A one time diagnostic makes sense when you need answers and have people internally who are ready to act on them. A part time consultant works great when you need regular optimization, but your business isn’t ready for a full-time employee. Just keep in mind: if design, development and research are all missing, a single consultant may need additional support to deliver the plan.

For work that requires daily decision-making across the business, a permanent internal team member may be a better fit. That requires a longer hiring process, but locks that expertise into your team for the long term as well.

If you just need short-term execution on a defined plan, bringing in a freelancer from sites like Upwork might be all that you need. You have to do a bit more of the candidate search and vetting yourself, but it’s often the least expensive route, for the first hire at least. The risk is that, if you don’t find the right person the first time around, those costs multiply quickly.

Often, the reality is that you need a mix of roles. You might want the security of a full-time hire alongside fractional support, or to bring in an expert for strategy before a more junior freelancer handles execution.

For these more complex situations, consider hiring platforms and fractional agencies like Right Side Up. They help you figure out the right mix of hires your business requires, whether that is bringing on board individual consultants, an agency team, or a full-time employee. Plus, their internal team consists of people who have done the job in-house, meaning they can evaluate talent against what your business needs.

Whether you choose to use a talent partner or ask peers for referrals, share a detailed hiring brief outlining your needs: “We need someone to investigate why paid traffic isn’t converting into qualified leads” is a lot more useful than “ Do you know a good CRO specialist?”

Choose someone with experience that resembles your situation

Once the interview process begins, ask candidates to talk through work that looks like yours. A notable client name can be reassuring, but it doesn’t tell you if someone understands your buying process or can work with your resources.

Consider the difference between selling a skincare product and a private charter service. Someone shopping for skincare might purchase during their first visit, whereas a charter client needs more details on availability, pricing, and travel details before booking. It’s very important for the consultant to understand what progress looks like in each situation.

Have a candidate share information about the customer’s decision, the obstacle they identified and how they chose what to work on. Then ask what they personally handled. A consultant who directed a large team has valuable experience, but every project needs someone to write copy, configure tests, and review results themselves, whether that’s the person you’d bring on or someone they’d oversee.

It’s also worth finding out how they would adapt their typical approach to the way your business operates. For example if in previous projects they worked with dedicated team members, how would they handle working with a smaller team?

The goal is to understand if their background fits how your business operates, and translates to the job you’re hiring for. A strong answer should make it easy to picture them stepping in and doing the work.

Find out how the results were achieved

A case study claiming a 30% conversion increase needs more context. That number alone doesn’t tell you what improved, how it was measured and if it drove business growth.

The candidate should walk you through the whole process from the initial problem to the end result. Was there an increase in product sales or clicks on a button? Did they perform A/B testing or just compare page performance before and after making changes?

For example, a product page started converting better after a redesign, but it had launched alongside a major discount. Without accounting for the promotion, it’s hard to know how much credit belongs to the new page. A thoughtful CRO consultant should be able to discuss that limitation.

They should also be completely comfortable talking about the project that didn’t go as planned and what they learned from it. Maybe customer interviews suggested shipping costs were the main concern, and their suggestion to show those costs earlier in the buyer’s journey didn’t improve purchases. A strong candidate won’t ignore that, they’ll explain how they diagnosed what went wrong, what they investigated next, and how they will adjust their strategy moving forward.

These types of conversations reveal how a consultant handles uncertainty. Because let’s be honest, you’re not going to win every test. When results fall flat, you need a consultant who won’t spin the data, can honestly break down what happened, and help decide what is the next plan of action.

Provide a specific example and ask for their approach

By discussing a real page or providing a simplified version of your problem during an interview, you can learn a lot about how they think and apply their knowledge.

Let’s say your website visitors reach a service page, but your request for a quote form isn’t converting. Ask the candidate what information they would want to know before recommending changes. An experienced candidate will ask informative questions that help connect the page to the buying decision:

Which ads or channels are bringing in people to the page?
Can visitors find pricing guidance?
What are the top questions customers ask before booking?

Compare this type of thought process with a weak candidate who immediately jumps to basic fixes like changing the color of a button or shortening the headline without an explanation. Either of these recommendations could be worth testing, however there has to be a real strategy to prioritize it.

You also want to pay attention to how they handle constraints, like if the form can’t be changed this quarter, can they pivot and find another smart way to investigate? Or if your tracking data is unorganized, what’s the first thing that should be verified?

This discussion should make their thinking and decision making process easy to understand. You shouldn’t need to be a CRO expert yourself to follow along, that’s their job, and exactly why you’re hiring them.

Agree on responsibilities, costs and what happens after

Working with a consultant means understanding what working together will involve. Two proposals with similar fees can leave your team with different workloads.

One CRO consultant may include research and recommendations, while the other offers copy, test setup and reporting as part of their services. The cost should be analyzed as a whole with what work is being done, and if any additional software, design, or development support is required. A cheaper proposal isn’t worth it if your marketing head has to spend 20 hours per week filling in the gaps.

Considering a consultant works with internal team members, ask how they work with other people too. A developer may flag a technical risk or a sales rep may explain what role the “unnecessary” form question plays in the buyer’s journey. A strong consultant will have good collaboration skills, absorb feedback and know how to adjust the plan based on information provided when needed.

Once you have chosen someone to hire, put the first phase in writing: outline the problem being investigated, the scope of work, who owns each task, and a timeline for reviewing progress. You should also specify which company data and assets you keep if the arrangement ends, such as research, account access, and test history.

By your first review, the CRO consultant should provide a clear breakdown of the problem, the work completed so far and the next steps. That is a reasonable standard of work to pay for, even before reliable conversion improvements begin to appear.

Hire a CRO consultant who can explain what’s worth fixing and why

The strongest reason to hire a CRO consultant is that they can help you make smarter decisions about where your visitors are getting stuck and what is worth doing to fix it. By the end of the hiring process, you should understand why that specific person’s experience fits your problem, how they are going to approach the work, and what additional work your internal team will need to contribute to make hiring a CRO consultant a worthwhile investment.

If you’re not able to answer these questions, keep looking. You’re investing time, budget, and part of your customer experience in their hands. The right CRO consultant must be able to explain how their recommendations will help more of the right customers choose you over competitors, and how you’ll know they worked.